Avoiding The Not-Invented-Here Trap
20 November 2026
Adi Gaskell urges business schools to see their research as not an end, but the beginning of a process with many benefits.
With the annual Drucker Forum in our rearview mirror, it's worth reflecting on what Peter Drucker's thinking can teach us about how universities and business schools create, curate, and share knowledge.
Drucker was a classic systems thinker, and systems thinking encourages us to look beyond traditional ways of generating knowledge and acknowledge that we're part of a broader ecosystem encompassing industry, think tanks, policymakers, alumni, and students.
IBM’s Stephan Haeckel gives us a useful framework against which to examine this transition. He explained that there are two types of organisations:
- A make-and-sell organisation produces based on its strengths and then tries to convince the market to buy
- A sense-and-respond organisation is the type of organisation that is constantly assessing the market and is agile enough to respond to what it finds.
If we want to use Toyota language, the former pushes whereas the latter pulls. When it comes to content, most universities and business schools firmly operate in the former way. Faculty members produce research, and comms then spin into gear to help promote that content, whether on the school’s own channels or elsewhere.
There's nothing inherently wrong with this. Academic research is central to what universities do. But should the research that's already been produced determine the entirety of what an institution communicates to its community?
A better approach
With a push approach, institutions only really talk about a topic if faculty have produced a paper on the topic. What’s more, institutions only talk about the topic through the specific lens covered in the paper. While that research may be groundbreaking, its reach is inherently limited when viewed through the broader, immediate needs of an institution’s community.
A pull-based approach looks entirely different. It starts by recognising that the community is interested in a topic and then gathering the best thinking available on the subject. Importantly, it requires that an institution avoids the “not invented here” trap and looks for knowledge from wherever it originates.
Think of what knowledge is within your grasp on the topic:
- Faculty’s research. This remains vital and provides crucial rigour and expertise, but it needn't be the beginning or end of the journey.
- Research from other universities. Drawing on relevant work from elsewhere can help build a more comprehensive understanding of the topic, with faculty providing interpretation and context.
- Research from government, think tanks and industry. These sources provide valuable context and different perspectives that make the picture that much richer.
- Alumni surveys. Understanding what’s happening in industry is crucial and can be undertaken far quicker than traditional peer review. Alumni networks offer a valuable, often underused, way to take the temperature of the business world.
- Qualitative discussions with executives, students, and alumni. Having participated in dozens of industry roundtables, I've repeatedly seen how much participants value discovering they're not alone in facing particular challenges. These conversations can provide a welcome dose of reality amidst the hyperbole surrounding new technologies.
Creating the cycle
Each of these sources of knowledge has value on an individual level, but their real potential comes when they’re combined.
Let's consider a topic that's front of mind for many organisations: AI governance.
The alumni survey might reveal that companies are struggling to establish meaningful accountability for AI-based decisions. Faculty could draw on existing research to establish what the evidence says, while an executive roundtable could provide practical insights into how organisations are grappling with the issue.
Thought leadership would, in this instance, be a report bringing together academic evidence, original survey findings and practitioner experience.
What’s more, the process should not end there, as it’s highly likely that it will uncover unanswered questions that could inform future research or even tuition itself. What began as an attempt to understand a particular problem becomes a continuous cycle of inquiry, synthesis, and learning.
Building credibility
None of these activities will likely be unfamiliar, and many may do several of them already. The issue is that they are too often conducted in isolation and not as part of a connected system.
The opportunity isn’t to do more, but to better join the dots between things already being done. A start can be made by viewing knowledge creation through the lens of community rather than solely through the eyes of faculty.
It’s a model in which content is no longer the final part of the knowledge production process, but a step in the creation of new knowledge. Academia and industry have always had strong links, but smarter use of content can help to ensure that the flow of knowledge between the two achieves its full potential.
Instead of simply broadcasting what professors have written, institutions can be positioned as trusted knowledge hubs that bring together not only original research but also intelligent synthesis and practitioner insights.
Adi Gaskell is a Thought Leadership Consultant & Future of Work Researcher who works extensively with universities and business schools. He can be contacted via email, and his writing can be found on Substack.